Not up to standard - Ex-Premier League referee questions Jackson sending-off against Newcastle
AFNEWS reporter
May 12, 2025
Not up to standard - Ex-Premier League referee questions Jackson sending-off against Newcastle
Former referee Keith Hackett has noted an error in Nicolas Jackson's dismissal in Chelsea's defeat by Newcastle United on Sunday.
Former PGMOL boss Keith Hackett has strongly criticised referee John Brooks for his handling of Nicolas Jackson's red card incident during Chelsea's game against Newcastle.
READ ALSO: Sandro Tonali will choose Manchester United if they secure Champions League football
The Blues had already endured a difficult start at St James' Park when Sandro Tonali scored early for the hosts.
READ ALSO: Chelsea finances: Blues announce biggest pre-tax loss of any club in Premier League history
However, things worsened in the 33rd minute when Jackson and Botman went down after an aerial challenge, leading to the forward's eventual dismissal.
Hackett criticises Brooks for relying on VAR
Hackett told Football Insider that Brooks should have shown Jackson a straight red card for his elbow on Sven Botman and accused him of waiting for VAR intervention to make the correct decision.
READ ALSO: HON. AARON UZODIKE: CUPP Gives Abia Speaker One Week Ultimatum, Set To Protest
"I ask myself, how can the referee see that illegal use of the arm or elbow as a yellow card offence?ÔÇØ, he told Football Insider.
READ ALSO: Eddie Howe Under Pressure as Newcastle Face Summer Exodus and Uncertain Future
"Once again, he sits on the fence and waits for the VAR lifebelt to be thrown to rescue him.
"This is without hesitation a red card offence, and in recent weeks I keep asking myself if [John Brooks] is up to the requirements of a Premier League referee.
READ ALSO: My husband threatened to burn me alive, woman tells court.
"He needs to start making the decisions on field in order to 'sell' the outcomes of his sanctions.ÔÇØ
READ ALSO: How Youth Was Killed By A Mentally Deranged Man In Delta | READ DETAILS
Despite an improved second-half showing, Enzo Maresca's men ultimately fell to a 2-0 loss at St James' Park.
READ ALSO: Roberto De Zerbi: Tottenham in talks with ex-Brighton boss about taking over as head coach
While the Italian manager did not criticise his striker publicly, Sunday's dismissal means Jackson will miss Chelsea's remaining two games and the first of the 2025-26 season through suspension, leaving the Blues without a recognised frontman in their chase to secure a top-five spot.
What's next for Chelsea?
Chelsea face Manchester United in their penaltimate Premier League fixture before facing Nottingham Forest on the final day.
Related Stories
David Raya is the best goalkeeper in the world, says Arsenal team-mate Kai Havertz after Sporting heroics
Sandro Tonali will choose Manchester United if they secure Champions League football
Chelsea finances: Blues announce biggest pre-tax loss of any club in Premier League history
Who has qualified for the 2026 FIFA World Cup? Who do England and Scotland play? Could Lionel Messi face Cristiano Ronaldo?
Eddie Howe Under Pressure as Newcastle Face Summer Exodus and Uncertain Future
Roberto De Zerbi: Tottenham in talks with ex-Brighton boss about taking over as head coach
""
— AFNEWS reporter