Many S-Court decisions no longer make sense - Justice Rhodes-Vivour
Afnews Editor
Mar 23, 2021
A retired Justice of the Supreme Court, Olabode Rhodes-Vivour, said yesterday that many previous decisions of the apex court should be laid to rest and never followed.
READ ALSO: JUST IN: President Buhari appoints Prof. Gambari as new Chief of Staff
Justice Rhodes-Vivour, who clocked the 70 years mandatory retirement age yesterday, spoke at a valedictory session the Supreme Court held in his honour.
READ ALSO: NSE Rewards 2020 Best JAMB Engineering Candidates With N16m | SEE PHOTOS
He took his last opportunity on the bench to address key issues affecting both the judiciary and the nation.
READ ALSO: I Will Not Allow Criminality As President, Peter Obi Declares
The retired jurist noted that the Supreme Court had on several occasions, held that it is absolutely bound by the doctrine of Precedent or stare decisis.
READ ALSO: Why You Should Arrest Peter Obi - Lauretta Onochie Tells DSS, Police | READ DETAILS
He said the doctrine, in effect, means "stand by your decisions and the decisions of your predecessors, however, wrong they are and whatever injustices they inflictÔÇØ.
Justice Rhodes-Vivour argued that abiding by such principle would ensure that the apex court continued to follow some of its previous judgements that no longer make sense.
READ ALSO: #EndSARS: As British Parliament Hears Petition, UK Govt Says It Won't Speculate On Sanctions
He said: "There are some Precedents that are clearly out of date, and should no longer be followed.
READ ALSO: Nigeria First Policy: Atiku dares Tinubu to drive Innoson car
"I am of the view that Precedents that no longer make sense anymore or are outdated should be laid to rest and never followed.ÔÇØ
On the issue of corruption, Justice Rhodes-Vivour stressed that it exists in all the countries of the earth, adding that Nigeria is no exception.
He said what should be done was to reduce it drastically, "thereby making our dear country an exception by building credible and transparent systemsÔÇØ.
READ ALSO: BREAKING: Offiong Edem qualifies for Tokyo 2020
The retired jurist further observed that elections in the country are always protracted due to the fact that the stakes are usually high.
READ ALSO: Why El-Rufai Was Returned To ICPC Custody?
He noted that most elections are often resolved by the courts, simply because most politicians are never satisfied with the results announced by the regulatory body charged with the conduct of elections, INEC.
READ ALSO: Sowore's Miscalculation and the Need to beat a Wise Retreat
Justice Rhodes-Vivour recalled that he had in a judgement he delivered in 2016, in an election dispute that involved the Governor of Cross River State, Emmanuel Udom, pointed out that a careful reading and understanding of decided authorities, would show that a Petitioner has an uphill task proving his petition in accordance with the Electoral Act.
READ ALSO: JUST IN: President Buhari appoints Prof. Gambari as new Chief of Staff
He, therefore, recommended that the Electoral Act should be amended to shift the burden of proof to INEC to prove that it conducted a fair and reasonable election.
READ ALSO: NSE Rewards 2020 Best JAMB Engineering Candidates With N16m | SEE PHOTOS
More so, the retired jurist noted that though he had in 2006, while serving as a Justice of the Court of Appeal, held in the case of Dokubo-Asari Vs FRN that where National Security is threatened or there is the real likelihood of it being threatened, human rights or the individual rights, must be suspended until the National Security can be protected or well taken care of.
READ ALSO: I Will Not Allow Criminality As President, Peter Obi Declares
He, however, made a U-turn on Monday, stressing that national security must be visibly threatened before anyone is denied his rights.
READ ALSO: Why You Should Arrest Peter Obi - Lauretta Onochie Tells DSS, Police | READ DETAILS
He said: No one should be denied his rights on the whims and fancy of anyone in authorityÔÇØ.
On the issue of inheritance, Justice Rhodes-Vivour said his judgement that abolished customary practices excluding female children from inheriting their father's estate, was informed by his vigorous study of the Bible.
READ ALSO: #EndSARS: As British Parliament Hears Petition, UK Govt Says It Won't Speculate On Sanctions
The retired jurist said he had in his verdict in Ukeje V Ukeje (2014) 11NWLR (Pt. 1418) P. 384, held that "a customary law which disentitles a female child from partaking in her deceased father's estate, is in breach of section 42(1) and (2) of the Constitution, a fundamental rights provision guaranteed to every Nigerian.
READ ALSO: Nigeria First Policy: Atiku dares Tinubu to drive Innoson car
"The said Customary law is void as it conflicts with session 42(1) and (2) of the Constitution. Female children are entitled to an inheritanceÔÇØ, he added.
On the issue of convicts, Justice Rhodes-Vivour said he was of the view that they should be allowed to serve their prison terms only after their appeals are exhausted.
"The reason being that some convicts serve several years in prison before their appeals are heard and decided.
READ ALSO: BREAKING: Offiong Edem qualifies for Tokyo 2020
"Their appeal may be found to be meritorious. They are then released. No compensation paid for the time spent in prisonÔÇØ.
READ ALSO: Why El-Rufai Was Returned To ICPC Custody?
Meanwhile, the Chief Justice of Nigeria, CJN, Justice Tanko Muhammad, in his address at the event, decribed Justice Rhodes-Vivour as "a rare gemÔÇØ.
READ ALSO: Sowore's Miscalculation and the Need to beat a Wise Retreat
He said the retired jurist diligently and meticulously offered unquantifiable services to Nigeria and humanity.
READ ALSO: JUST IN: President Buhari appoints Prof. Gambari as new Chief of Staff
"We are all here today to felicitate with an accomplished jurisprudential iconoclast that has offered the best of his intellect to the advancement of the legal profession through his several years of inimitable adjudications.
READ ALSO: NSE Rewards 2020 Best JAMB Engineering Candidates With N16m | SEE PHOTOS
"His Lordship is a rare gem and unblemished symbol of humility and piety.
READ ALSO: I Will Not Allow Criminality As President, Peter Obi Declares
"His proficiency in the dispensation of justice, which is anchored on his mastery of law, presents him as a man of honour and scholarship.
READ ALSO: Why You Should Arrest Peter Obi - Lauretta Onochie Tells DSS, Police | READ DETAILS
"His judgments are not only incisive but also analytical and opulent by all standards.
"His robust contributions to the development of our jurisprudence are inviolable and fascinating.
READ ALSO: #EndSARS: As British Parliament Hears Petition, UK Govt Says It Won't Speculate On Sanctions
"His impeccable attention to details in every matter before him is alluring and salutary as wellÔÇØ, the CJN added.
Related Stories
REVEALED: How All Progressives Congress (APC) Played Into The Opposition Hands Ahead Of 2027 - Sumner Sambo Warns
I Will Not Allow Criminality As President, Peter Obi Declares
Why El-Rufai Was Returned To ICPC Custody?
Sowore's Miscalculation and the Need to beat a Wise Retreat
Tinubu Breaks Silence on Hardship, Inflation, Power Crisis - Vows Nigeria Will Overcome Economic Storm
"Terrorists Have Outgunned Our TroopsÔÇØ - Ndume Raises Alarm Over Boko Haram War, Sends Urgent Message To Tinubu
""
— Afnews Editor