Breaking: Shell loses case against 4 Nigerian farmers in Dutch court
chuks oti
Jan 29, 2021
A Dutch appeal court in The Hague has ruled that the Nigerian branch of Shell has to pay compensation to some Nigerian farmers who have been litigating against the company for 13 years.
READ ALSO: Mother's Day: Abia Government Liaison Officer Honours Women, Says Mothers Shape Future Leaders
The court reached the decision today. The amount of compensation must be determined later, a Dutch newspaper reported.
READ ALSO: TOP STORY: Abia LGA Finance In Jeopardy, As ALGON Chairman Michael Nwoke Alleges Threat To Life
According to the ruling, Shell is liable for two oil spills.
READ ALSO: NYSC warns Borno corps members against illegal motor parks
The case also revolved around a third claim, but the court will only rule on that later.
READ ALSO: Bloodbath At Wedding: Bandits Kill 13, Abduct Many In Midnight Attack In Kaduna Community
The third leak was caused by sabotage and the court needs additional information to know whether Shell has done enough to secure the pipeline against the sabotage.
READ ALSO: FRSC: Edo records 3 deaths in 4 road crashes
Milieudefensie, the Dutch branch of Friends of The Earth, brought the lawsuit in 2008 on behalf of four Nigerian farmers.
READ ALSO: How a Catholic Priest Slumped and Died While Delivering Homily in Delta Church
The case revolved around the spills from underground oil pipelines.
READ ALSO: "Ikwuano Locked Down For Alex OttiÔÇØ - Monday Ubani SAN Sends Strong Message To Opposition
According to the plaintiffs, their villages have become virtually unliveable due to the spills.
READ ALSO: Ofuji Ndị Igbo Sets 2026 Agenda, Promises Greater Community Engagement
The polluted soil became unusable and fishing grounds were lost, causing them to lose their income.
Shell said that the spills are the result of sabotage and that the company is therefore not liable for them.
READ ALSO: FUNNY! The baby isn't my baby -Regina Daniels reacts time viral baby photo
The company also argued that the pollution is always cleaned up properly, while the farmers say that hardly anything ends up in practice.
Milieudefensie argued that pipelines are often outdated and that Shell is doing too little to prevent sabotage.
READ ALSO: PDP: Why I May Cancel Approval To Use Rally Venue - Wike
At first instance, in 2013, one of the farmers was proved right by the court.
READ ALSO: Mother's Day: Abia Government Liaison Officer Honours Women, Says Mothers Shape Future Leaders
The other farmers' demands were rejected. Both camps filed an appeal.
READ ALSO: TOP STORY: Abia LGA Finance In Jeopardy, As ALGON Chairman Michael Nwoke Alleges Threat To Life
Today's judgment can also still be appealed at the Dutch Supreme Court.
READ ALSO: NYSC warns Borno corps members against illegal motor parks
The case has set a legal precedence in how far multinationals in the Netherlands can be held responsible for actions of their overseas subsidiaries.
READ ALSO: Bloodbath At Wedding: Bandits Kill 13, Abduct Many In Midnight Attack In Kaduna Community
Royal Dutch Shell argues that saboteurs are responsible for leaks in underground oil pipes that have polluted the delta. The company also argued that it should not be held legally responsible in the Netherlands for the actions of a foreign subsidiary.
READ ALSO: FRSC: Edo records 3 deaths in 4 road crashes
In 2013, The Hague District Court ordered Shell Nigeria to compensate one of the four farmers involved in the case for making it too easy for saboteurs to open a well head that leaked onto his land. However, the court cleared Shell of blame in pollution of the other three farmers' land and ruled that Shell's Dutch parent company could not be held liable.
READ ALSO: How a Catholic Priest Slumped and Died While Delivering Homily in Delta Church
Both sides appealed and judges ruled in 2015 that Shell could be held to account in Dutch courts for its actions in Nigeria.
READ ALSO: "Ikwuano Locked Down For Alex OttiÔÇØ - Monday Ubani SAN Sends Strong Message To Opposition
The judges also ordered Shell to give the plaintiffs access to documents that could shed more light on the cause of the leaks and how much Shell management knew about them.
READ ALSO: Ofuji Ndị Igbo Sets 2026 Agenda, Promises Greater Community Engagement
Shell discovered and started exploiting Nigeria's vast oil reserves in the late 1950s and has faced heavy criticism over the years from activists and local communities over spills and for its close ties to government security forces.
Friends of the Earth, which is supporting the Nigerian farmers in their legal battle, argues that leaking pipes are caused by poor maintenance and inadequate security and that Shell does not do enough to clean up spills.
READ ALSO: FUNNY! The baby isn't my baby -Regina Daniels reacts time viral baby photo
*With background report by AP
Related Stories
Bloodbath At Wedding: Bandits Kill 13, Abduct Many In Midnight Attack In Kaduna Community
"Ikwuano Locked Down For Alex OttiÔÇØ - Monday Ubani SAN Sends Strong Message To Opposition
Mother's Day: Abia Government Liaison Officer Honours Women, Says Mothers Shape Future Leaders
Why ICPC Is Prosecuting Mike Ozekhome Over a London Property Deal That Has Shaken Nigeria's Legal Circle | READ DETAILS
Ofuji Ndị Igbo Sets 2026 Agenda, Promises Greater Community Engagement
How a Catholic Priest Slumped and Died While Delivering Homily in Delta Church
""
— chuks oti