N7.65BN FRAUD: APPEAL COURT FIRES ORJI UZOR KALU, SAYS "YOU HAVE A CASE TO ANSWERÔÇØ
Afnews Editor
Apr 25, 2019
The Court of Appeal on Wednesday okayed the dismissal of the no-case submission filed by a former Abia State Governor, Orji Uzor Kalu, in response to the N7.65bn fraud charges filed against him by the Economic and Financial Crimes Commission.
In a lead judgment by Justice M.L. Garba, the Court of Appeal said Justice Mohammed Idris, then of the Federal High Court in Lagos, was right to have on July 31, 2018 dismissed Kalu's no-case submission and ordered him to put in his defence.
The appellate court equally dismissed the appeals filed by Kalu's co-defendants - Slok Nigeria Limited and Ude Udeogu - challenging the jurisdiction of Justice Idris to continue hearing the case after he was elevated from the Federal High Court to the Court of Appeal.
READ ALSO: 2023: Peter Obi, Datti Ahmed To Storm Abia Saturday 14th January 2023
Justice Garba held that contrary to the appellants' contention, Section 396(7) of the Administration of Criminal Justice Act 2015, which empowers a high judge to continue to hear a part-heard criminal matter after being elevated to the Court of Appeal, did not offend the constitution.
READ ALSO: Lampard Speaks, Gives Details Why He Can Be Sacked
The appellate court, therefore, ordered the defendants to return to the high court to put in their defence.
READ ALSO: B00M: Imo Teachers Storm Government House Amidst Governor's Challenge | SEE DETAILS
The prosecution had last year closed its case in the 12-year-old trial after calling 19 witnesses.
READ ALSO: Nigerian Army Opens Up On The Allegation Of Creating 'Unknown Gunmen', 'Biafra National Guard'
But rather than open their defence, Kalu and his co-defendants filed no-case submissions.
READ ALSO: Why El-Rufai Was Returned To ICPC Custody?
But before Justice Idris could hear and rule on the no-case submission he was elevated to the Court of Appeal.
READ ALSO: Kaduna Winners Chapel Bomb Suspect Moved to Abuja (SEE REASON)
In order to prevent the case from being transferred to another judge to start afresh, Kalu's lawyer, Prof. Awa Kalu (SAN), activated Section 396(7) of the ACJA and applied to the Court of Appeal's President, Justice Zainab Bulkachuwa, to give a fiat to Justice Idris, so that he court return to the high court to conclude the case.
As a result, Justice Idris was given a fiat to continue hearing the case, with a condition that he must conclude it by the end of September 2018.
READ ALSO: I Will Not Allow Criminality As President, Peter Obi Declares
On July 31, 2018, the judge dismissed the defendants' no-case submissions and ordered them to open their defence.
READ ALSO: Sowore's Miscalculation and the Need to beat a Wise Retreat
But rather than proceed to open their defence, Kalu sought a six-week adjournment to embark on a trip to Germany to have a surgery for an undisclosed ailment.
READ ALSO: ABIA: PDP, Plotting To Lure Our Candidates Of Ukwa La Ngwa Extraction - APGA Chairman Raises Alarm
The defendants later challenged the jurisdiction of the judge to hear the case, arguing that he was no longer a judge of the high court.
They also filed an application seeking a stay of proceedings pending the outcome of their appeals.
Justice Idris dismissed both
READ ALSO: 2023: Peter Obi, Datti Ahmed To Storm Abia Saturday 14th January 2023
At a time, the judge revoked Kalu's bail for travelling to Germany without the court's permission.
READ ALSO: Lampard Speaks, Gives Details Why He Can Be Sacked
He ordered him to submit himself to the EFCC within 24 hours of his return to the country.
READ ALSO: B00M: Imo Teachers Storm Government House Amidst Governor's Challenge | SEE DETAILS
On January 23 when the case last came up in court, the prosecutor, Mr Rotimi Jacobs (SAN), fumed about Kalu's repeated absence from court, alleging that the former governor, now a senator-elect, was taking the court for a ride, noting that despite the court's order he did not turn himself in to the EFCC.
READ ALSO: Nigerian Army Opens Up On The Allegation Of Creating 'Unknown Gunmen', 'Biafra National Guard'
"He (kalu) kept on campaigning for his senatorial ambition, slapping the court in the face; his attitude is unbecoming,ÔÇØ Jacobs said, while urging Justice Idris to continue hearing in Kalu's absence.
READ ALSO: Why El-Rufai Was Returned To ICPC Custody?
But in response, Justice Idris said he could not proceed with the case as the second fiat given him by the Appeal Court President had expired in November 2018.
READ ALSO: Kaduna Winners Chapel Bomb Suspect Moved to Abuja (SEE REASON)
While adjourning the 12-year-old case indefinitely, Justice Idris held, "This matter was listed today because it was adjourned till today for defence. What has happened is that the last fiat that was issued by the President of the Court of Appeal has expired at the end of November 2018.
"On the 10th of January, 2019, I received a fresh fiat in respect of some matters that I have started and some new matters but this particular case was not mentioned.
READ ALSO: I Will Not Allow Criminality As President, Peter Obi Declares
"For this reason, I have a strong feeling that I shouldn't continue with proceedings in this case unless there is a further directive from the President of the Court of Appeal.
READ ALSO: Sowore's Miscalculation and the Need to beat a Wise Retreat
"I should not proceed further, otherwise I might be acting without authority.
READ ALSO: ABIA: PDP, Plotting To Lure Our Candidates Of Ukwa La Ngwa Extraction - APGA Chairman Raises Alarm
"In the circumstance, I am of the view that further proceedings shouldn't go on until I receive further information by way of fresh fiat from the Court of Appeal President. As soon as I receive further instructions, hearing notice will be sent to counsel.ÔÇØ (Punchng)
Related Stories
REVEALED: How All Progressives Congress (APC) Played Into The Opposition Hands Ahead Of 2027 - Sumner Sambo Warns
I Will Not Allow Criminality As President, Peter Obi Declares
Why El-Rufai Was Returned To ICPC Custody?
Sowore's Miscalculation and the Need to beat a Wise Retreat
Tinubu Breaks Silence on Hardship, Inflation, Power Crisis - Vows Nigeria Will Overcome Economic Storm
"Terrorists Have Outgunned Our TroopsÔÇØ - Ndume Raises Alarm Over Boko Haram War, Sends Urgent Message To Tinubu
""
— Afnews Editor